SMT Vs Through Hole Technology – Advantages and Disadvantages
SMT Vs Through Hole Technology – Advantages / Benefits and Disadvantages of SMT over Through Hole Technology in Terms of Cost, Assembly, Soldering.
SMT Vs Through Home Technology – Which is better in terms of Cost, Assembly and Reliability? This debate has been ON for several years now. Let us discuss the advantages and disadvantages of SMT Vs Through Hole Technology in some detail.
The benefits of SMT or Surface Mount Technology over Through Hole Technology are available in both design and manufacturing. Surface mount components or SMD Components are small and can be mounted on either side of the SMT PCB and have gained widespread usage by electronic companies.
SMT Vs Through Hole – Advantages of Surface Mount Technology
Among the most important design-related benefits or advantages are significant savings in weight and real estate (Size of the PCB) and electrical noise reduction. A SMD Component can weigh as little as one-tenth of their conventional through-hole / thru hole electronic components. This causes a significant reduction in weight of the Surface Mount Assembly (SMA). Because of their smaller size, surface mount components occupy only about one-half to one-third of the space on the printed circuit board. This leads to smaller and slimmer mobile phone, tablets, laptops and other such gadgets.
SMT also provides improved shock and vibration resistance as a result of the lower mass of SMD components. Shorter lead lengths of Surface Mount Components offer benefits of lower parasitic that reduces propagation delays and reduces package noise.
Manufacturing Benefits of Surface Mount Technology over Through Hole Technology
In addition to design benefits, SMT also provides many manufacturing benefits. These benefits include reduced board cost, reduced material handling cost, and a controlled manufacturing process.
Routing of traces is reduced, size of the board is reduced, and number of drilled holes is also reduced. A smaller board with fewer drilled holes will naturally cost less.
If the functions on the surface mount board are not increased, the increased inter-package spacing made possible by smaller surface mount components and a reduction in the number of drilled holes may also reduce the number of layer counts in the printed circuit board. This will again lower the board cost.
SMT Vs Through Hole – Disadvantages of SMT over Through Hole
Since all electronic components are not available in surface mount, the actual area savings on a board will depend on the percentage of through-hole components replaced by surface mount components. Depending on the component mix, the three types of surface mounting provide different levels of benefits.
The above benefits of Surface Mount Technology don’t necessarily means that SMT assembly will always cost less. It depends when and how SMT is used.
- Surface Mount Soldering Guide – SMD Soldering
- SMT Soldering and PCB Assembly Techniques
- Printed Circuit Board: Design, Diagram and Assembly
- How to Solder – Hand Soldering Tutorial
- RoHS Guide in Electronics: RoHS, WEEE and Lead-Free FAQ
- PCBA Tools – Suppliers of PCB Assembly Tools, Equipment and Consumables